Cairns Mayoral candidates asked to show sustainability credentials – no response from Margaret Cochrane
Three of the four Mayoral candidates for the Cairns Regional Council area, Val Schier, Ian Thomas and Bob Manning responded to an environment and sustainability survey sent to all Mayoral and councillor candidates in the Cairns, Cassowary Coast and Tablelands areas.
“Unfortunately Margaret Cochrane of Community Alliance did not complete a survey, calling into question her interest in this issue. This is cause for great concern for a potential Mayor in a region that heavily depends on the integrity of our unique natural environment for our social and economic base”, says Sarah Hoyal, CAFNEC Coordinator.
The survey questions were designed to give voters an understanding of candidate views on a range of environment and sustainability issues in Far North Queensland. Questions could be answered yes or no, but candidates were also able to make additional comment or attach policy documents to provide further detail on their positions.
All candidate responses are available at http://cafnec.org.au/election2012/Election2012_Front_Page.php
Sarah Hoyal said, “Based on the responses we received, from an environmental perspective CAFNEC believes that Val Schier responded with the most measured concern for the environment, while Ian Thomas would be our second recommendation to voters.“
A summary of the three Mayoral candidates’ responses are summarised below and their detailed responses are in the attached table.
CLIMATE CHANGE
Val Schier and Ian Thomas were both supportive of allocating funds to undertake actions documented in Council’s Climate Change Strategy (2010 – 2015) to reduce impacts on, adapt to, and build community resilience to climate change. Bob Manning indicated he had no knowledge of this document. Val Schier said “It is important that Council acts locally to reduce the region’s impact on climate change by reducing energy and emissions. It is equally important for council to take action to adapt to the changing climate which will be unavoidable given the region’s geographic location.” Ian Thomas indicated he had “…an exciting project which will explain my proposed initiatives.”
DAINTREE POWER
All three candidates supported the implementation of a sustainable stand-alone power supply for the Daintree area that has no adverse impact on the environment or World Heritage values of the area. However both Ian Thomas and Bob Manning also support extending mains power to the Daintree which CAFNEC believes is contrary to their answers to the previous question. Val Schier stated that she believed that this mains power option would also be more costly as well as environmentally damaging than a stand-alone supply for the Daintree.
DAINTREE FERRY CONSERVATION LEVY
Bob Manning did not support the reinstatement of a conservation levy on the Daintree Ferry to allow a Conservation Infrastructure Management Fund that Council could use for the purchase of land and other conservation outcomes. Ian Thomas stated that it was “…A difficult question – only in regard to the effect of additional costs on tourism operators who are currently struggling. Definitely something to be tabled as Cairns emerges after this recession.” Val Schier would support a levy if it was “legally possible” and that it “would be for tourists to pay and not locals”, and “would operate in a similar way to the Reef Tax which all visitors to the reef pay to contribute to its protection and management.”
CAIRNS AIRPORT EXPANSION
Bob Manning did not think that the Cairns airport expansion (with the loss of 100 hectares of mangroves) would “become an issue in the foreseeable future”. Both Val Schier and Ian Thomas stated their opposition to the mangrove destruction.
MULGRAVE AQUIFER EXTRACTION
Only Val Schier was willing to clearly state that she would oppose the extraction of water from the Mulgrave Aquifer if it is shown to have negative environmental impacts, and instead support the implementation of local water efficiency measures to better manage our current water supply. Both other candidates made cautious, non-committal replies.
DREDGING TRINITY INLET
Both Bob Manning and Ian Thomas support the further dredging of Trinity Inlet (in addition to current routine dredging) to allow large cruise ships to enter the port. Bob Manning would support this “…subject to the necessary studies being done and approvals obtained” while Ian Thomas stated that he would support the dredging “Only on the basis of no detrimental effects – we do not need another Gladstone.” Val Schier believes “It’s critical that the recent feasibility study on dredging the inlet is made public and any possible environmental impacts of additional dredging are known; this includes any impacts in relation to the disposal of dredged sediment.”
OTHER ENVIRONMENT ISSUES
All three candidates agreed – with some reservations – to supporting rates incentives to encourage biodiversity conservation and sustainable building design on private property and will seek to ensure the improvement of public transport and bicycle infrastructure in the region. All three candidates also supported Council working with other partners (such as Landcare and Natural Resource Management bodies) to manage both current and emerging biosecurity threats (e.g. Myrtle Rust, tramp and electric ants, tilapia, pigs etc).
NO RESPONSE FROM COMMUNITY ALLIANCE
No members of Community Alliance, led by Margaret Cochrane, answered our survey. However a quick review of their website (www.commmunityalliancecairns.com) reveals they are keen to see ‘red tape reduction’ and ‘streamlining’ of development applications. Sarah Hoyal, CAFNEC Coordinator says: “On first reading to most voters this Community Alliance policy may sound fairly reasonable… BUT fast-tracking development has historically resulted in negative outcomes for the environment.”
MAYORAL FORUM
CAFNEC attempted to organise a Cairns Regional Council Mayoral Environment Forum for the last week prior to the local government election – however only two of the four candidates (Val Schier and Ian Thomas) indicated they could attend. We acknowledge that this forum was organised with limited notice, but were disappointed that as a result we were obliged to cancel the forum as we did not believe two candidates was sufficient to provide for a robust debate.
Sarah Hoyal – CAFNEC Coordinator – 4032 1746/ 0488 681 916

